top of page

Law and Society

Updated: Sep 25, 2023

(aka Sociological Legal Theory)

Now we have read a lot about how philosophers endeavor to dissect what "law" meant, how about how law interacts with our society? Why did capitalism arise and how does equality and freedom play a role in it? Carry on to learn more!





Emile Durkeim (1859-1917)

  • due to society's movement from religion to secularism, the law is less concerned about punishment than compensation

    • punishment -(derived from)→ crime → common conscience

  • types of social solidarity:

    1. mechanical solidarity: uniformity of values, absence of division of labor

    2. organic solidarity: division of labor, high degree of interdependence


Max Weber (1864-1920)

  • revolves around the idea of 'rationality'

    • which diverges into 'formal' and 'substantive' legal system - is the system 'internally self-sufficient'?

  • attempts to explain the evolution of capitalism in western societies:

    • law is relatively autonomous - "fundamentally related but not determined by economic factors"

    • English law system is less "substantive" than the Roman law (formal in the sense that legal writings have to be formatted in a specific way)

    • lawyers are specialized to cater to their commercial clients

    • binding of precedents - 'cautelary jurisprudence' (laws are drafted to prevent future litigations)

    • this leads to formal rationalization of law

  • Why should people obey the law (hence, legitimate domination)?

    1. traditional - obeying because of long tradition of obedience to power

    2. charismatic - obeying because of the characteristics/personal charms of the sovereign

    3. legal-rational - obeying because of the recognition of the legality of the rule and the right of the authority

      • What is good about legal-rational authority?

        • 'Formalistic impersonality' - judges can impartially apply the rules

It is noteworthy to point out that many of Weber's detractors found his analysis of domination too simplistic.


Karl Marx (1820-1895)

  • historicist: social evolution is unavoidable due to historical forces

  • views the origins of laws in two ways:

    1. sprung from economic base (instead of moral)

    2. 'class instrumentalism' - expresses the will of the dominant class (but do they have a unified consensus)

    3. latter Marxist - mediation of classes (connection between different classes)

  • rejects 'consensus' model for the evolvement of our society:

    • the presence of 'conflict' between opposing camps (i.e., the powerful and the powerless) of the society, where law is used to keep dominant group in control

    • instead of the unitary of society and only conflict in personal level

  • argues that revolutions will inevitably lead to classless communist society which made law unnecessary - this invites criticism as law is also used to regulate economy

  • rejects the notion of justice and rule of law as it is a concept dependent on material conditions, hence equating it to communism

    • latter Marxist (E.P. Thompson) - embraces the idea of rule of law

  • repudiates the idea of individual human rights as capitalism and selfish

    • distinguishes 'right of citizens' (political rights) from 'right of men'

    • argues that 'right of men' is problematic as it induces egotism

  • to achieve true individual liberty:

"triumph of human elements over material world"

Jürgen Habermas (1929)

  • the consequences of capitalism and a strong centralized authority is the intrusion of 'lifeworld' (which meant "common norms and identities")

  • hence, need 'communicative action' which is based on equality and freedom

  • differentiates 'law as medium' from 'law as institution':

    1. law as medium - general rules that overpowers a state

    2. law as institution - incorporates shared values/norms as an institution


Michel Foucault (1926-1984)

  • disciplinary power instead of law plays an engaging role in every areas of our life

  • coined as 'genealogy' - analysis of the nature and function of power (e.g., prisons) and how discipline arise

  • practices : techniques

    1. 'cellular' : "draws up table"

    2. 'organic' : "prescribes movements"

    3. 'genetic' : "imposes exercises"

    4. 'combinatory' : "arranges 'tactics' in order to obtain the combination of forces"



 

Credits


The information provided above is all credited to Raymond Wacks's Philosophy of Law: A Very Short Introduction.


P.S. If you are really interested in exploring the world of jurisprudence (on 'What is law?"), make sure to check out his book!!


Recent Posts

See All

The tragedy of the 11th Amendment

The Eleventh Amendment to the US Constitution is a rather arcane and little-known section of the Constitution. It is interesting, however, because it has a far larger, and more nefarious, impact on th

Comentários


bottom of page